Things That Scare Me

June 14, 2012
By

I don’t know about you, but every once in a while I stumble across information that really gives me pause for concern. Recently I read a few pieces on personal caregivers that put a fright into me.

With an aging population already in place and the first wave of Baby Boomers starting to turn 65, Personal Care Aides and Home Health Aides are on top of the list of the projected fastest-growing occupations in the country between 2010-2020. In 2011, the direct-care workforce totaled about 4 million workers and by 2020, that group is expected to be roughly 5 million strong, or the single largest occupational group in the US. These direct-care workers, according to PHI (one of the sources of my reading), “provide an estimated 70 to 80 percent of the paid hands-on long-term care and personal assistance received by Americans who are elderly or living with disabilities or chronic conditions.”

For many elderly Americans or those chronically disabled, these workers are a lifeline – and not only for the patients but for their families and friends as well. They help clients bathe, dress, and negotiate their activities of daily living.

At MPTF we prize these workers and recognize the significant value they bring to our world the world of our residents and their families. For me personally, one of the most hurtful parts of our LTC struggles a few years ago was the unfair criticism levied directly at MPTF’s caregiving practices and indirectly I felt, at those who were providing the care. I can’t imagine more dedicated and committed members of the MPTF team – then and today – and celebrate their contribution to the MPTF mission.

We are right to be concerned, however, how some of these direct caregivers are being treated, especially Personal Care Aides and Home Health Aides who are providing this kind of care at home. Anecdotally, I have heard from friends in this field that the wage rates and working conditions are sub-standard, and the data I’ve seen bears this out. According to the statistics in the PHI study previously cited, many of these workers live in households that receive public benefit such as food stamps, Medicaid, or housing, child care, or energy assistance. In other words, they are barely hanging on themselves!

When we think about where we’re headed in the area of caregiving in the future, particularly the growing need for home health aides of various kinds, this kind of data has to make you nervous. I have to tell you, it does me. Amongst the many other issues we are grappling with on a daily basis, we need to ask whether we are treating those individuals in whose trust we are putting our society’s most vulnerable without the economic dignity they deserve. Doesn’t that worry you?

About Bob Beitcher


Bob Beitcher is the President and CEO of the Motion Picture & Television Fund. He has been a senior executive in the entertainment industry for 30 years, having held leadership roles at Jim Henson Productions, Paramount Pictures, Panavision and MacAndrews & Forbes Media Group. Bob has been an MPTF board member since 2007. He became interim CEO in 2010 and was named permanent CEO in 2011.

Related Posts:

  • No Related Posts

Tags: , , ,

  • marie lhossein

    I am a member of local 724 and 80 I was just thinking taking the certificate to become a caregiver I am already 59 and was hoping to retire at 62 so it would give some extra income having a disabled husband I sure will need more then just a 900$ pension.
    But now that you wrote about how the caregiver are not making any money I have second thoughts evendough my friends tell me that I would make a great caregiver because I am so compassinate and patient with elder poeple.
    Thank for your letter.
    Marie Lhossein

  • Denise Loverro80

    If you are passionate pursue your idea..compassionate caregivers when working privately can make good money..not in an institution..I’m an RN and I know people like yourself are rare and very much needed

  • Sandy Cole

    So Bob, What do we do to enhance these individuals and give them there due and fair share of pay for their services. I support you and applaud you dedication to MPTF. Sandy Cole. Namaste’

  • Rmervis

    Wouldn’t it be grand if you took all the money for celebtity golf tournaments and big hotel gala’s and put it straight to work for our elderly and bed bound seniors? Just sayin’

  • http://www.facebook.com/Revolution9 Richard Stellar

    I believe that most of the criticism regarding the standard of care given to those at the long term care unit were leveled at management.  The level of care that my mother received from those that bathed, fed and nurtured was exemplary (with maybe one exception) – The care providers at that level were great.  However, the management level seemed to fall far short of this.  This is who ‘we’ were critical of, and are thankful that the then CEO left.

    As critical as ‘we’ were, ‘we’ are now hopeful that under your leadership the level of care will once again be the gold standard that people fought for.  The dedication and commitment of those who cared for my mother was never questioned.  

    I’m hopeful that under your leadership, the global concern for a re-assessment of dementia treatment is addressed at the MPTF.  ’We’ are in your corner.

  • Bob Beitcher

    Not sure what you’re “just sayin.”  All the monies earned from our charitable events are already ploughed back into our programs.

  • Bob Beitcher

    Dear Sandy,

    Thanks for your comment.  I think the answer to your question is very complex and speaks to everything from government reimbursement and priorities to the Affordable Care Act to legislation around living wages.  There’s some irony, for example, that many of these caregivers themselves do not have health insurance.

  • Bob Beitcher

    Dear Denise,

    I agree with your advice.  I think you need to enter into something with your eyes open but at the same time if you’ve got the passion and the talent, this is truly doing wonderful work for others.  Sometimes the “pay” is a mix of the tangible and intangible.  Anyone working in a charitable setting can vouch for that.

    Bob

  • Bob Beitcher

    Dear Marie,

    If you have the talent, compassion, and patience, and think you would enjoy working with elder people, you should certainly look into this pursuit.  Only you can judge whether the pay will be adequate and meet your needs.  This is a very personal decision.  The rewards for this kind of work, though, need to be evaluated broadly; in other words, it’s never just about the money.

    Good luck with whatever you choose.

    Bob

  • Bob Beitcher

    Dear Richard,

    Thanks for your words of encouragement and please know that the staff and management will continue to strive to do the job at the highest level of care.

    Bob

  • http://www.billsmitrovich.com/ Smitty

    Dear Bob,  So wonderfully refreshing to see this open dialogue from the MPTF management and your office. This demonstrates the different and progressive leadership that you have brought to our fund.  It is certainly obvious that you care deeply, and want to captain this sometimes unruly and deeply important MPTF ship on a healthy and sustainable journey.  One can only do that by looking ahead and forward.  It’s obvious that you are.  Your letter points up a very troubling future for a majority of American citizens, and more directly the majority of ‘our own’.  Because the motto and purpose is “taking care of our own” I hear, and feel your words, as a baby boomer kid, and as a member of our community.    Like so many service jobs in this country, and I include teachers, firemen and women, and any service for the public well being, it seems a systemic problem.  While our politicians continue to be “funded”, “informed” and, dare I say, “bought” by the powerful corporate special interests, we have little chance for the real bold changes that are necessary for a stronger public citizenry.  The MPTF relies on funds from corporate funds, no question.  But I ask you in earnest; Which is the larger donor?  The public donors or the corporate donors?  The estates of stars and shakers included.  Or, do we need our own P.A.C. (?)…to help the Fund’s cause and/or the cause of the unions that represent our best chance at getting health workers a better living wage and work conditions. 
    Did I mention corporate fraud, greed and corruption?  Another systemic problem.  Maybe another time….But in the meanwhile, Good on ya Bob Beitcher, and Ken Scherer, for your dedicated and caring leadership.  So too, for all the compassionate workers at MPTF that help to make it the healing and humane institution it is.  Here’s to many, many, more years!  

  • JOAN LUCAS

    We all know I turn 75 this year….I am so tickled by these more recent comments.  In 1945 I turned 7 years old at the end of WWII and  remember “The War Effort”  and of course these ensuing years where we have become friends and trarde goods and services…culture.  I only ever asked that my friend Larry get to stay at THE BEST….He is and I am grateful.  JOAN  The lady of the Snows

  • formeremployee

    Bob, I agree with you that the reward is more than the money. But those who have chosen this work often do not evaluate it carefully enough. They take the positions because it paid “well enough” and then realize a few years later, that it means long days, hard work, missed meals and breaks, and often emotionally draining days. Those are the ones that do a half job, and  give the job a bad name.. To the rest, we salute you! And there should be more pay for the fantastic job you do caring for our elders!

  • http://www.facebook.com/Revolution9 Richard Stellar

    Joan, you don’t look it!  Happy Birthday!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/betty.p.madden Betty P Madden

    Quality of life at the end of life needs our attention and involvement. Care givers need proper training and education guidelines in the handling of the elderly in their daily routine. The job of caregiver is both physical and emotional care giving so that is why programs need to be developed today to train and facilitate this important career opportunity.  

  • Bob Beitcher

    Dear Smitty,

    Thanks for your kind words.  They are very, very much appreciated, especially since I know they come from a guy who cares so much about the industry and its seniors

    Bob

  • Bob Beitcher

    Betty,

    Well said.  This is highly specialized work and work that requires training, mentoring, and systematic feedback.  I couldn’t agree with you more.

    Bob

  • Bob Beitcher

    Dear Formeremployee,

    You are absolutely right in saying that the work is demanding in so many different ways — time, energy, family life, emotional life — and that you had better be prepared for what’s coming or you won’t do it well.   And if you’re not going to do it reallly, really well, this isn’t the job for you.  THere’s too much in the balance for anything but the very best performance.

    Bob